en

Google Admits Working for Pentagon's Drone Murder Program

by Andre Damon on World Socialist Web Site

Just an innocent private IT company? Yeah right, it's part of the military-industrial complex, profiting from empire's endless wars and up to its elbows in blood. Helping Pentagon blow up Afghan weddings.

In another milestone in the growing integration between the military-intelligence complex and Silicon Valley, Google's parent company Alphabet has confirmed that it has provided software to identify targets used in the illegal US government drone murder program.

Since initiating its drone assassination program in 2009, the United States claims to have killed close to 3,000 "combatants" in drone strikes. Internal military documents show that for every one person targeted by a drone strike, nine bystanders are killed, meaning that the true toll of the US military's airborne terrorism campaign in Yemen, Somalia, Afghanistan, Pakistan and Iraq potentially rises to the tens of thousands.

According to the American Civil Liberties Union, "A program of targeted killing far from any battlefield, without charge or trial, violates the constitutional guarantee of due process. It also violates international law, under which lethal force may be used outside armed conflict zones only as a last resort."

Google's complicity with the drone murder program implicates the company in the criminal activities of the US military, sparking outrage among employees after executives admitted the collaboration in an internal memo last week, according to a report by Gizmodo.

Sensitive to both the potential legal ramifications of its actions and to the hostility to America's criminal wars both inside and outside the company, Google stressed in a statement that its collaboration "is for non-offensive uses only," saying "the technology flags images for human review."

But this absurd and unserious pretense, aimed to provide talking points to an uncritical, state-controlled media, is the equivalent of a Mafia getaway driver claiming he is not an accomplice to murder because he did not pull the trigger.

The US government has claimed the right to use drones to assassinate American citizens anywhere in the world, including within the borders of the United States. In 2011, the Obama administration assassinated Anwar al-Awlaki, a US citizen, with a Predator drone strike in Yemen, then murdered his 16-year-old son, Abdulrahman al-Awlaki, in another drone strike two weeks later.

Google's partnership in such nefarious operations threatens it not only with legal sanction around the world, but also with serious commercial repercussions. The company's decision to proceed despite these dangers points to the increasingly vital role of military contracts in the business operations of the major technology giants.

The Defense Department spent at least $7.4 billion on artificial intelligence programs last year, and is expected to spend even more this year, with much of that amount flowing to corporations like Alphabet (Google), Amazon, and Nvidia, whose artificial intelligence capacities reportedly outstrip those of in-house Pentagon programs.

Over the past year, Google, Facebook and Twitter have all announced measures to censor the information their services present to users, promoting "authoritative" and "trusted" news outlets over "alternative" viewpoints, which include news outlets that expose and denounce US war crimes. Facebook, which of all the technology companies has been the most unabashed in its determination to censor its platform, has explicitly said it expects user engagement to drop as a result of its demotion of "viral" videos and promotion of "trusted" news sources, such as the New York Times.

As these companies expect some drop-off in consumer demand as they impose increasingly restrictive censorship measures, lucrative defense contracts are a means to pad their bottom line and align their financial interests ever more closely with the war-making and repressive operations of the American state.

The technology giants have moved to impose censorship measures at the same time that the Pentagon has concluded that it has found itself in an "AI arms race," as the Wall Street Journal put it this month. Facing the rapid economic rise of substantial military powers, such as Russia and China, who are able to develop and implement new technologies without the massive logistical burden of the countless wars, overseas deployments, and destabilization operations engaged in by the United States. US military planners have come to the conclusion that the only way to retain the American military advantage in future conflicts is to integrate Silicon Valley into the warfighting machine.

The Pentagon has devised the so-called "Third offset" strategy to defeat the "pacing threat" from China by focusing on "autonomous learning systems, human-machine collaborative decision-making, assisted human operations, advanced manned-unmanned systems operations," and "networked autonomous weapons" as the Economist recently put it in the cover story of an issue titled "The next war."

This strategy revolves around the recruitment of the US private technology sector, which remains the most developed in the world. As the Economist put it, the United States "continues to dominate commercial AI funding and has more firms working in the field than any other country."

Speaking at a conference last year, Marine Corps Col. Drew Cukor, the head of the so-called "Project Maven" in which Google is a key collaborator, declared the US in the midst of an "AI arms race," adding, "Many of you will have noted that Eric Schmidt is calling Google an AI company now, not a data company."

He added, "There is no ‘black box' that delivers the AI system the government needs... Key elements have to be put together … and the only way to do that is with commercial partners alongside us."

In order to streamline the reciprocal exchange between the technology giants' vast computational power, artificial intelligence capabilities, and massive database of sensitive user data and the US military's virtually limitless budget, the Pentagon has set up a series of partnerships with Silicon Valley. In 2015, the Pentagon set up a private-public funding vehicle known as the Defense Innovation Unit Experimental (DIUx), headquartered just minutes from Google's main campus in Mountain View, California.

A 2016 meeting between Google Executive Chairman Eric Schmidt and US Defense Secretary Ashton Carter about the Defense Innovation Advisory Board for the DoD

In 2016, the Pentagon set up an entity called the Defense Innovation Advisory Board, aiming to "bring the technological innovation and best practice of Silicon Valley to the US Military," chaired by none other than former Google Chairman Eric Schmidt.

Last fall, Schmidt complained about the reluctance of those working in the technology sector to collaborate with the Pentagon, bemoaning the fact, "There's a general concern in the tech community of somehow the military-industrial complex using their stuff to kill people incorrectly."

But beyond leveraging the tech giants' artificial intelligence capabilities for guiding missiles and selecting victims, the open secret of the Pentagon's collaboration with Silicon Valley is that, behind the scenes, vast quantities of sensitive, personal user data is likely being funneled to the Pentagon and intelligence agencies for the purposes of surveillance and targeting.

As Lt. Gen. John Shanahan, who is closely involved in Project Maven put it at a conference last year, "On the far end of the scale, you see Google. They don't tell us what they have, unless anyone from Google wants to whisper in my ear later."

The integration of companies like Google into what had previously been known as the military-intelligence apparatus is creating a vast system of state repression previously unknown in human history. Preparing for great-power conflict requires, as the Pentagon's recently-released National Defense Strategy puts it, "the seamless integration of multiple elements of national power—diplomacy, information, economics, finance, intelligence, law enforcement, and military."

Censorship and surveillance are the linchpin of this emerging military-technology-intelligence nexus. As the United States prepares to wage "hot" wars against "peer" militaries such as Russia and China, the growth of domestic anti-war sentiment will be combatted through the use of mass censorship, aided by artificial intelligence, with political profiling on the basis of social media communications.

The World Socialist Web Site is leading the fight against this drive to censorship and war. In August 2017, we published an open letter demanding that Google end its political censorship of search results, which have led to a massive fall in search traffic to left-wing and anti-war web sites. In January, the WSWS published a call for all "socialist, anti-war, left-wing and progressive websites, organizations and activists" to join an international coalition to fight Internet censorship. We call on all workers and young people seeking to defend democratic rights to contact the WSWS and join its struggle for socialism.

  • 32 comments
    last comments from World Socialist Web Site
    Kpguitarz 2018-03-11T06:30:05  0

    Thank God Ai and Technology is only as smart as their creators and those they rule over or I would be worried. All that National Insecurity has left a hole big enough for Jupiter to pass through. Now back to your regular scheduled left right paradigms

    Jason Kennedy 2018-03-09T05:32:22  3

    So long as Google hires inclusively, facilitating extra-judicial murder will sit just fine with the fake-left progressives.

    syzygy556 2018-03-08T23:30:37  1

    the only way google will go down if someone from there starts a google like site and takes all the employees with him or her

    Palimpsestuous 2018-03-08T22:51:23  1

    The whole point of a corporation is to eliminate all human characteristics from an organization comprised of humans with the sole legal purpose of enriching humans who don't even work there. Talk about your destructive, unaccountable bots.

    Our collective insanity is allowing corporations to exterminate humankind as if there were no other way to organize means of production and distribution.

    Greg 2018-03-08T18:44:47  0

    Lots of integration and precedents.

    "The potential influx of military-intelligence personnel into the legislature has no precedent in US political history." -The CIA Democrats

    What could they possibly be preparing for?

    "The integration of companies like Google into what had previously been known as the military-intelligence apparatus is creating a vast system of state repression previously unknown in human history. Preparing for great-power conflict requires, as the Pentagon’s recently-released National Defense Strategy puts it, “the seamless integration of multiple elements of national power—diplomacy, information, economics, finance, intelligence, law enforcement, and military.”"

    jb 2018-03-08T17:45:07  2

    Thank you Andre for another great exposure.
    Intelligence gathering AI drone police vehicles on our city streets before long? Armed and unarmed. That, together with sky drones, - no where to turn. (except of course revolution). And the petty bourgeois social democrats and patriots will agree, "well if you're not up to something, why are you worried?"

    If you know someone in the military ask them to start reading wsws.org.

    Brendan 2018-03-08T15:38:02  7

    Google have been selling mapping services to the U.S. military and intelligence agencies for many years:

    "In 2004, after taking over Keyhole, a mapping tech startup cofunded by the National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency (NGA) and the CIA, Google developed the technology into Google Maps, an enterprise version of which it has since shopped to the Pentagon and associated federal and state agencies on multimillion-dollar contracts. In 2008, Google helped launch an NGA spy satellite, the GeoEye-1, into space. Google shares the photographs from the satellite with the US military and intelligence communities. In 2010, NGA awarded Google a $27 million contract for “geospatial visualization services.” "

    Top Google executives have had close relationships with the U.S. military, due to Google's involvement in the “Enduring Security Framework” (ESF) program and the "Defense Industrial Base":

    "Emails obtained in 2014 under Freedom of Information requests show Schmidt and his fellow Googler Sergey Brin corresponding on first-name terms with NSA chief General Keith Alexander about ESF. Reportage on the emails focused on the familiarity in the correspondence: “General Keith . . . so great to see you . . . !” Schmidt wrote. But most reports overlooked a crucial detail. “Your insights as a key member of the Defense Industrial Base,” Alexander wrote to Brin, “are valuable to ensure ESF’s efforts have measurable impact.”

    The Department of Homeland Security defines the Defense Industrial Base as “the worldwide industrial complex that enables research and development, as well as design, production, delivery, and maintenance of military weapons systems, subsystems, and components or parts, to meet U.S. military requirements.”

    The Defense Industrial Base provides “products and services that are essential to mobilize, deploy, and sustain military operations.” Does it include regular commercial services purchased by the US military? No. The definition specifically excludes the purchase of regular commercial services. Whatever makes Google a “key member of the Defense Industrial Base,” it is not recruitment campaigns pushed out through Google AdWords or soldiers checking their Gmail."

    https://wikileaks.org/googl...

    Ed Hightower 2018-03-08T15:00:14  6

    Thanks for this important analysis. I agree that Google et al are buoying themselves for a consumer backlash by soliciting Pentagon dollars. It is unsettling news that they use AI for killing. As the article says, they must be using it to target internal dissent as well. This shows the importance of the WSWS-led drive against Google and Facebook censorship.

    Skip 2018-03-08T14:07:53  4

    Most alarming news. But not unexpected. The ruling class is always anti-humanity at every stance. It's pure self interest at work that leads to our destruction on every level.

    Eric Sommer 2018-03-08T13:43:42  6

    Google’s deep CIA and NSA connections go back to its origins. Part of the funding for its earliest operations came from a CIA owned venture capital company, publicly acknowledged as such and as a means for 'pertinent' investments. Many more details on Google's sordid CIA/NSA relationships can be found in this article. https://eric-sommer.com/goo...

    Vivek Jain 2018-03-08T13:30:11  0

    precedents: http://www.nytimes.com/2001...

    Vivek Jain 2018-03-08T13:29:09  6

    anyone suing Google? drone murder lawsuits should take every penny.....

    Ric Size 2018-03-08T13:19:07  2

    Think Robocop 2 (1990) in terms of AI military/police drone technology. This is what the ruling class will unleash to maintain order. Coincidentally, this film predicted the bankruptcy & privatization of Detroit. Directed by Irvin Kershner.

    PeterthePainter 2018-03-08T12:57:32  3

    We were only talking about this in the pub last night. We all agreed that if you are not formallly at war with a country yet you attack them using drones then its extra judicial killing which is murder isn't it?

    Charlotte Ruse 2018-03-08T12:33:34  4

    Google maps directed the drones to the intended target, killing thousands of innocent civilians.

    And now Google working with the NSA wants to censor information that is NOT considered authoritative--really meaning state-run propaganda. The NSA does NOT want the public to know about the war crimes committed by the US Government.

    teri 2018-03-08T10:18:16  5

    Letting computer algorithms decide who lives and who dies; why would any sane person think this is a good idea? Even I, cynical as I am, cannot keep up with the level of awful, horrible, mind-numbingly bad ideas being foisted on the human and nonhuman world alike by some of our fellows.

    Shit. Homo sapiens sapiens. Yeah, we think we are just so smart, we put the word "wise" in there twice.

    M Green 2018-03-08T08:48:38  15

    Rather than being a "milestone" of any sort, the only surprising element might be if Google were to take a principled stand to deny its software or other assistance in killing "terrorists" (aka resistance) to the US military. The CIA flew its drugs out of Laos and Cambodia on commercial airlines and then developed their proprietary airline, Air America, to do so. Wealthy Americans loaned their boats to the CIA to sabotage Cuba; worked with it in Iran-Contra and funded and facilitated the death squads world-wide, but especially in Central America (see Scott & Jon Lee Anderson: "Inside the League: The Shocking Exposé of how Terrorists, Nazis, and Latin American Death Sqauads Have Infiltrated the World Anti-Communist League" Dodd-Mead, 1986). Jeff Bezos rents $600,000,000 of Cloud to the CIA, uses the WaPo as the Pentagon's sounding board, and the Washington Examiner has nominated him for CIA director. The NYT suppressed Bush's massive illegal wiretapping until after the 2008 election. Most of America's rich and powerful are eager to collaborate with the military-intelligence requests, and the occasional truant like Joseph P. Nacchio of Quest, who refused to turn over customer data to the NSA months before 9/11, are punished as he was by a trumped up federal prosecution (in his case insider trading) for which he got 6 years and served 4½. There are no milestones. The mask is simply coming off.

    Google's alliance with the US state has long been public. While David North enthusiastically pronounced of the Egyptian Revolution, “We are witnessing in this ancient land the first stirrings of a new epoch of world socialist revolution.”https://www.wsws.org/en/art..., and Johannes Stern opined “In spite of its political problems, the revolution, which began on 25 January 2011, heralded the opening of a new period of the world socialist revolution.” https://www.wsws.org/en/art..., Eric Schmidt & the State Deparment were busy channeling its energies elsewhere as Julian Assange revealed in a much-neglected account of his June 2011 meeting with Google Elites in which they pumped him for tips on how to use social media to channel energies for social change:

    "I realized Eric Schmidt might not have been an emissary of Google alone. Whether officially or not, he had been keeping some company that placed him very close to Washington, D.C., including a well-documented relationship with President Obama. Not only had Hillary Clinton’s people known that Eric Schmidt’s partner had visited me, but they had also elected to use her as a back channel. ...Gen Next also backs an NGO, launched by Cohen toward the end of his State Department tenure, for bringing Internet-based global “pro-democracy activists” into the U.S. foreign relations patronage network. The group originated as the “Alliance of Youth Movements” with an inaugural summit in New York City in 2008 funded by the State Department and encrusted with the logos of corporate sponsors. The summit flew in carefully selected social media activists from “problem areas” like Venezuela and Cuba to watch speeches by the Obama campaign’s new-media team and the State Department’s James Glassman, and to network with public relations consultants, “philanthropists,” and U.S. media personalities. http://www.newsweek.com/ass... An expression of this nouveau revolutionary current is found in the NYT account of how “Wael Ghonim, a 29-year-old Google marketing executive, who was browsing Facebook” secured a place in history by helping to lead that revolution. “Spring Awakening: How an Egyptian Revolution Began on Facebook” http://www.nytimes.com/2012...

    Recall too the split among the US elites about how to manage the discontent as Frank Wisner Jr. flew to Egypt to give full support to Hosni Mubarak, which "Foreign Policy" described as "he went off the reservation of the Obama administration’s policy and forced the administration to distance itself from him..." http://foreignpolicy.com/20... Wisner's father, in turn, was one of the founding four CIA officers memorialized in Evan Thomas's "The Very Best Men: Four Who Dared: The Early Years of the CIA" whose key accomplishment was to collude in the 1950's with Philip Graham of the the WaPo in Operation Mockingbird--a coordination of all the major US media under one umbrella to tell slightly varying verisions of a glorified US capitalism so it could be warmly embraced by the masses they led. Eric Schmidt and Google walked into some very well-worn shoes. As a bonus feature, when major domestic covert ops like the assassination of JFK occurred, deeply embedded CIA officers and agents like Dan Rather appeared on the scene to give the exclusive report of the Zapruder film in which--directly contrary to fact--he reported that the final after the final shot Kennedy's head "went forward with considerable violence." This is only news to people whose thoughts have been elsewhere.

    лидия 2018-03-08T07:17:28  8

    Just as Ford company had helped South America's "their SOB" against the workers, the oppression of imperialist states made possible by the big business.

    лидия 2018-03-08T07:15:22  6

    "But this absurd and unserious pretense, aimed to provide talking points to an uncritical, state-controlled media, is the equivalent of a Mafia getaway driver claiming he is not an accomplice to murder because he did not pull the trigger."
    Me it reminds of a story of the "innocent" guillotine-maker for Nazis.

  • write comment

This material is distributed without profit for research and educational purposes.
The views expressed are solely those of the authors or commentators and may or may not reflect those of Radios.cz.

Text to Speech by: ResponsiveVoice-NonCommercial licensed under 95x15
website no use cookies, no spying, no tracking
to use the website, we check:
country: US · city: Columbus · ip: 18.221.141.44
device: computer · browser: AppleWebKit 537 · platform:
counter: 1 · online:
created and powered by:
RobiYogi.com - Professional Responsive Websites
00:00
00:00
close
 please wait loading data...